The perfect blend of good food, good books, and whatever else I toss in.

Showing posts with label information. Show all posts
Showing posts with label information. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

A subscription costs HOW much?

My work is done for the semester and I have officially reached the halfway point. During the last bit of course project polishing yesterday, I got an email from one of my subscription discussion lists about Elsevier. The email pointed to an article criticizing Elsevier's subscription prices. Now, I'm not naive; I know that libraries pay lots of money for subscriptions to journals and databases that they provide to their patrons. For universities, this cost is huge (for my university, knowing how many databases I have access to--well over one hundred--I cringe to think what the cost is) because of the need for research material for students and faculty, and it's even more if the university provides both print and digital access. But finding out what the cost is for some of the journals that Elsevier provides was, in a word, shocking.

One of the titles mentioned in the above article is Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, a journal with a subscription price of a mere $20,930 to US subscribers (the libraries in Japan must pay $31,000 a year for the same title). I took a look at the subscription list that is available to view to verify the price and to see how many issues that annual subscription pays for. It looks like there are 100 issues, as this subscription includes several titles, not just one; however, that still amounts to $209 per issue. And I found a few other gems: Analytica Chimica Acta for 1 year is $11,994 (48 issues which amounts to about $250 per issue), Annals of Nuclear Energy for 1 year is $4637 (12 issues which amounts to about $383 per issue), and Atherosclerosis--a medicine journal--for 1 year is $5955 (12 issues which amounts to about $496). This was just from skimming through the list of titles beginning with an A. Take a look for yourself; you can find the librarian subscription list here: http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find/journalpricing.cws_home/subscrippricelistlibr/description.

I find it hard to justify these exorbitant costs especially since, as Rob Kirby said in a letter to his colleagues, "We mathematicians produce the papers, serve as editors, and serve as referees, all for free (except of course for our support by our universities and employers). Then with relatively small improvement to the product, publishers turn around and sell it to our libraries at (in many cases) a very high price" (view the full letter). Those academics in the field do the groundwork, and Elsevier (and other publishers of scholarly work) take the final product and sell it for a huge mark-up. And for the most part, they've done it with impunity. Libraries bow their heads and find ways to shoulder the subscription prices, sometimes having to make cuts in other areas in order to continue receiving a title considered "vital." This is exploitation, and it is wrong.

Tim Gowers very eloquently explores this issue in two posts on his blog. The first post, from late January, notes four of the biggest criticisms of Elsevier's business practices and explores ways in which academics and libraries could take a stand, but the key to both solutions relies on strength in numbers to gang up on the "bully" and tell Elsevier that the academic community will not put up with their exorbitant subscription prices. The second post was made in response to Elsevier's open letter defending their practices. Gowers addresses the points that Elsevier tries to make and raises some valid questions.

One thing that I question is the legality and ethics of this. The public is essentially paying twice for the research being closely guarded by Elsevier and other publishers. #1 The public pays the taxes that helps to fund the research grants that universities apply for to fund the projects that allow the faculty to do the research that's used to write the articles sent to the journal for publication. #2 The public pays the taxes or tuition that help to fund the libraries that purchase the published journals with the articles written to explain the research. Still with me? It's criminal to force libraries to pay through the nose for information the public served by the library has already paid for. I agree with Gowers in that it is time for a change--this system is broken and it's long been time for us to throw it away. Research is done with the intent to provide important/new/meaningful knowledge for the field its done for and to help make advances that better us--not to help publishers line their pockets.

If you're an academic and wish to show your support and protest against Elsevier's practices--and hopefully send a message to other journal publishers--please consider adding your name to The Cost of Knowledge, a website for researchers who are taking a stand and promising to refrain from publishing, refereeing, or performing editorial work on any Elsevier publication. Once I receive my degree and/or begin submitting my work for publication, I will be adding my name to this list as well.

Friday, August 12, 2011

"A Blueprint For Great Schools"

I am a member of several professional organizations, including the CLA, or California Library Association. Today, through this network, I saw a message posted regarding a California Department of Education News Release about a report that was released on Tuesday that addresses the many challenges currently in California public schools and the recommended strategies to address them. The report is called A Blueprint For Great Schools. The person that posted the report noted that nothing is mentioned about improvement in the libraries of the public schools. I read through the report to find that this seems to indeed be the case.

While the report provides recommendations to solve many problems and issues that certainly have helped to create the dire situation many of our public schools are in, I feel that it ignores the huge benefit school libraries can provide if time, effort, and money is invested in these bodies as well. I couldn't leave my thoughts unspoken, so I responded to the report by sending a message to the email provided in the news release. My response is below:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
To Whom It May Concern:

I was very interested to see the outcome of the "Blueprint for Great Schools Report" and related plans for impovement in California schools. Having previously been a teacher in the California public school system, I've had first-hand experience with the extreme challenges faced both by the students and by the teachers and administrators who provide their education. I was pleased to note a lot of my own observations being addressed in the report, including the high percentage of ELs in our classrooms and the instructional challenges this poses; a need for changes in student and school accountability that currently doesn't consider challenges caused by the student's background or the local community's resources; and a need for a partnership between schools, parents, and the community to support each student's education. I truly think that recognizing these and other issues our state schools face is an important step towards re-establishing California as a leader in education in the nation.

However, I was disappointed to see no mention made of improving the schools' libraries and media centers. According to the report, the principles these strategies follow "take into account the changing demands of a 21st century knowledge-based, technology-driven economy and society."[1] If you are serious about creating an environment that truly prepares students for a 21st-century world, you will not discount the resources and support that a school library can provide, and I hope that you will consider amending your strategies to include school libraries. The report notes that "With the adoption of new standards and assessments, there is urgency in ensuring that schools have more rapid and ready access to appropriate instructional materials — including digital materials — to support learning."[2] Librarians have a lot of expertise on resources of all types and on finding out which ones are perfect for any topic. Taking a class to the library is not all about story time. Librarians often are creating their own "lessons" that use library resources to support material that is a part of classroom curriculum. While it may seem like teachers would be able to do the same thing, librarians have an uncanny ability to find and combine resources that teachers don't know about simply because they were not trained in the same way.

Teachers and school librarians are working towards the same goal: to educate California's youth. However, they go about it in different ways. Classroom teachers must focus on the curriculum they teach; there is a lot of subject matter they must expose their students to in order to explain the world around us and show their students the why and how of things. Librarians explain information--how to find good information; how to tell if information is false, misleading, or biased; what resources are available to students wanting to find information (and getting them to think of other, more effective resources than Google!); how to collect pieces of information from various resources to build a whole picture; the list goes on. There are so many sources of information and so many traps and pitfalls in the world of information--including keeping your privacy intact--and classroom teachers lack the training and the knowledge to show this to their students. We live in a digital age where information is infinite and everywhere. In this "technology-driven...society" as it is classified in the report, we have to teach our students how to effectively navigate the vast wealth of information there is without being overwhelmed or becoming victim to those who use the digital world to prey upon others. You will find that librarians are the best teachers of this lesson--it is, after all, what we are trained to do.

I'm in no way trying to degrade what teachers do; I'm only trying to make you aware of what librarians do as well. Librarians and teachers are part of the solution. Bringing our schools back to life and creating strong learning environments will require not only strengthening our teachers, but also strengthening the libraries that provide such valuable classroom support. You can't build a bridge without making sure it has the necessary support to stand, or the bridge will collapse. Education is the bridge between our students and the world they live in; make sure the bridge is sound enough not to fail them.

Thank you for considering my position. I look forward to the revival of our state's education.

[1] "Strategies for a New System of Education." Retrieved from http://www.cde.ca.gov/eo/in/bp/bpstrategies.asp

[2] "Curriculum and Assessment." Retrieved from http://www.cde.ca.gov/eo/in/bp/bpstrategy2.asp
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If I get a response, I will make sure to add it to another post.

Friday, June 10, 2011

An indication of the times

For millions of people, the often-comforting, sometimes-frustrating presence of the Internet is one that we can no longer imagine being without. The near-infinite amount of information that is now at our fingertips boggles the mind. In many ways, our lives are easier; shopping, keeping in touch with long-lost friends and family, and looking up the process for changing oil in your specific make/model of car are only a very few examples of things that the Internet has made almost effortless. However, there have been some fallout from our willingness to integrate this beast so completely into our lives. The idea of a right to information is butting heads constantly with the right of an individual's privacy in many forms. It also doesn't help that people don't realize a very important truth about the Internet: nothing posted online can ever be guaranteed privacy. Someone somewhere will be able to access it, read/view/listen to it, and distribute it to anyone he/she pleases.

But I'm deviating from the focus of this post: our access to the Internet. It has by far become the norm. Even people in countries we would not necessarily associate with technology are hooking up to the Internet via computers and mobile devices. Our world is truly developing into a global community, one where all the best and worst of humanity is laid bare for all to see. Well, almost all--there are still areas of the world where the government has a say in what their citizens get to view online.

I think that the best indicator of our continued reliance on the Internet and how much an individual's worth can be measured by their online presence is a recent declaration by the United Nations. The UN's report, dated May 16, explains the importance of the Internet for many various reasons relating to other human rights and the means of human progress. According to the UN, blocking people from the Internet is a human rights violation. The report goes on to say that Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is applicable to the forms of information exchange that take place on the Internet, thereby protecting them and access to them as it would other forms of information exchange. One interesting part of the report explains the very specific circumstances in which a restriction of the Internet would not constitute such a violation. Simply because the government is "trying to keep the peace" is not reason enough. It put me in mind of the Egyptian government's attempt to block the online coordination of rebels a few months ago when the old government was (relatively peacefully) overthrown.

"What does this have to do with libraries?" I hear you ask. Well, perhaps not much overtly, but at the heart of the purpose of public libraries is a free exchange of ideas. Libraries are perhaps the best physical embodiment of the First Amendment in the US Constitution and the right of free speech and freedom of expression guaranteed by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. They provide the forum for us, the people, to find any information on any topic that we want. They provide the resources for us to explore any idea, no matter how controversial, so that we can make our own informed opinion of what we believe. And now with the rise of the Internet that I've been talking about during this whole post, libraries have included access to the online world and all the resources that it can provide as well. Libraries have continued to advocate by example the free exchange of ideas on all platforms--digital and otherwise--something that the UN has officially come to recognize as well.

Okay, on to a lighter topic, I do have another recipe to post: mocha pudding cake. This is a slow-cooker recipe, which makes me think that it may not take much tweaking to adapt the recipe to a dutch-oven heated over a campfire or with barbecue coals.

What you'll need:
1 1/3 c. sugar
1 c. flour
1/2 c. butter--melted
4 eggs--lightly beaten
1/3 c. unsweetened cocoa
1/4 c. chopped pecans
2 tsp. instant coffee granules
1/2 tsp. ground cinnamon
1/4 tsp. salt
2 tsp. vanilla extract

What you'll need to do:
1. In a large bowl, add the sugar, flour, cocoa, instant coffee, ground cinnamon, and salt. In a smaller bowl, mix together the eggs and vanilla extract.
2. Add the egg mixture to the large bowl along with the melted butter and pecans. Mix everything together until well-blended.
3. Lightly grease the bottom and sides of a 3-quart slow cooker. Add the batter and cover.
4. Cook on the low setting for 2 to 2 1/2 hours until set around the edges but still soft and slightly gooey in the center. Let stand for 30 minutes (still covered) and serve warm with vanilla ice cream.

Friday, May 13, 2011

Yet Another Reason to Support your Public Library

I’m thinking of a place where you can go for free computer classes that can help you learn basic computer programs. This same place will have free workshops on everything from Chinese Medicine to the culinary arts to knitting blankets. You’ll also be able to pick up the latest book by Charlaine Harris for free, then log on to check your email (for free) before getting your pressing question about the national health care plan answered. Meanwhile, your 9-year-old son is getting (free) help with his homework assignment for Math before choosing a copy of “Shrek 3” to take home and watch. A coffee for you and an orange juice for him wrap up your visit to this magical place where all this happens on a regular basis.

What place could I possibly be talking about? The public library.

Our society has turned into one where money is no longer the only currency: information is the new fad. And libraries, information brokers since the dawn of time (not literally, but you know what I mean), are uniquely positioned to take advantage of this. And the kicker is that they provide their services for free. An article I read mentioned that if the idea of libraries had been proposed now, there would be no way that they would have been created. I have to agree; there would not be nearly enough funding to create enough public libraries across the nation, and people would likely begrudge the thought of any more money being squeezed out of what little they have by the government. In a time when it seems that nothing is free anymore and people’s ability to afford more than the bare minimum is almost non-existent (and in some cases it is), we should be valuing the benefit of the public library.

Lucky for us, it seems that a significant percentage of the population does. ALA’s 2011 The State of American Libraries Report has shown that visits to the library and the utilization of library services continue to steadily increase. People know and appreciate what the library can provide for them. After all, the library is the only free place you can go that connects people with the information they need and helps to bridge the Digital Divide (a claim Google would not be able to make).

If you’re not convinced that the library is still valuable with all of the digital and Internet resources you now have at your fingertips, I encourage you to take a look at this article. I think that the first point is the most important: “Libraries serve the disenfranchised.” Right now, there are a lot of have-nots in the country. People can’t afford the hardware/software/Internet connection/Wi-Fi/etc (the Digital Divide issue I just mentioned) that is steadily becoming the norm for looking up government forms (ex. unemployment benefit forms), searching and applying for jobs (many if not most companies only post open positions online), and staying connected with family and friends (social networking). So what happens to those that don’t have a computer but still want to be able to do these things? They go to their local library.

Sony, Google and Apple are all under fire for various reasons regarding their customer’s privacy. Sony’s PS3 Network was hacked, and millions of users’ information was obtained in the attack. Google and Apple are currently dealing with lawsuits that allege their violation of users’ privacy in the type and amount of information that their smart phones have been secretly collecting. I take comfort that I will never have this problem in the library: “Libraries are interested in your privacy.” The librarian is no stranger to defending her patrons’ privacy, and the ALA also offers guidelines on confidentiality and privacy in the library.

The public library—and what it has to offer—is a role model for society.

Friday, February 11, 2011

The World of the Miscellaneous

Prior to this semester, the term "miscellaneous" heralded ideas of things "left over," things that don't really have a place in which they belong. A particular book required by one of my classes has brought new meaning to the term and really changed my previous world-view (perhaps "refined" is the better term) of information.

Online information has exploded. New content is being created every day. There is no way to organize it all--too much information is out there for any concerned cataloging effort to ever catch up. However, David Weinberger's book Everything Is Miscellaneous: The Power of the New Digital Disorder is showing me that organizing it really isn't necessary. Part of the power of how interconnected things are is being able to start on a page about a food item's nutrition facts, bounce to pages of recipes, and end up at a restaurant at a vacation destination that specializes in dishes of that food. We become our own gateways into the vastness of available knowledge.

One thing Weinberger talks about is a third-order organization. This particular organization seems best explained through examples of sites that allow users to place tags on digital objects--like Flcker. The third-order introduces the idea that digital items, because of their lack of limitations with physical space, can be classified and located in an infinite number of places. A picture of a sunset in Hawaii could be labeled as "Hawaiian sunset," "Hawaii," "sunset," "tropical locations," "romantic beaches," "2007 summer memories," "wedding destination," "ocean view," etc. There is no limit to the number of tags that can be put onto a picture, which makes it meaningful and more accessible to more people--since not everyone would classify it as the same thing. That one picture could then be used in just as many collections with pictures of similar tags. A user could make a collection of "2007 Summer Memories" including that picture and a number of other pictures from the rest of the vacation; or the user could create a "Romanic Places" collection that includes that picture and a number of other pictures that are all tagged with "romanic." The possibilities are now endless. Information has truly become miscellaneous, but in doing so its accessibility has infinitely increased.

I know that I owe a recipe post, but unfortunately I haven't been doing a lot of experimenting lately. Class has required a large amount of reading, and I've been using every spare minute for keeping on top of all the reading I need to do. As a result, I've been sticking to well-known and quickly-made recipes, most of which I've already posted. I will however take some time for a couple of tips for things I discovered in the past couple of weeks.

1) If you need shredded chicken for any recipe (I use it for making enchiladas), cooking it in a crock pot with chicken broth, onions, and spices (and a can/bottle of beer if you're feeling really adventurous) is a good way to add flavor. Just put everything in the crock pot in the morning, set the crock pot on the low setting, and it'll be ready by the time you have to make dinner. For an added bonus, you can save the broth to use for making soup later. Just freeze in a container until you need it.

2) Add a surprise to your cupcakes by adding candy. You can chop up chocolate mints and mix in to chocolate batter or add candy-bar minis to cupcakes before you bake them for a yummy little something extra.

3) For frosting details on cakes or cupcakes, ziplocks are a easy replacement for professional icing bags.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Wikileaks and me

I know that many people have weighed in on Wikileaks's release of classified US government documents. My purpose in bringing it up and adding my voice to the chorus is not to chastize them, although I have very mixed feelings about their decision to post the cables as expressed in one of my posts on my class's discussion board:

"I don't know what the answer is in regards to information relating to national security. On one side is this feeling I have that the citizens of a country have the right to know what their government is doing, so [government] transparency--something that has been promised in the past but never truly attained--would be necessary for this to happen. Yet, I can understand why such information should be kept from the public eye--leaks can happen like the one Wikileaks was just involved in, and information that's dangerous for other ("enemy") countries to know could be released that harms us in the end."

So on the topic of the ethics of the leak, I'm still on the fence. I honestly don't know whether it's right or wrong. Maybe it'll depend on how many lives are negatively effected by this (and I mean ordinary citizens, not political leaders).

My real concern lies with the fact that the Library of Congress has decided to block all access to Wikileaks from all of their computers, public and staff computers alike. The Library of Congress issued a statement, which is also posted on their own blog as to why they did this. In their statement, they say that as federal agency they are "obligated to protect classified information." This would make sense if the whole world also didn't have access to these cables. However, I fail to see the logic behind this reason for blocking documents posted on a website that is publically accessible from 1) public libraries, 2) public wireless access points, and 3) home computers (I would also bet the leaks can be uploaded on mobile devices too). I hate to tell the US government, but the documents are no longer classified if everyone can access them and read them. They get credit for trying to prevent people from reading them, including addressing federal government workers[1] (and even students looking to get future jobs in the federal government are being told to question the wisdom in looking at the documents[2]); but they won't be able to put "the genie back in the bottle"[3], a term the Progressive Librarians Guild uses in their statement admonishing the LoC for its move to block Wikileaks.

On a related matter, the Library of Congress also houses the Congressional Research Service. For those who don't know what the CRS is, it is a group of researchers in the LoC that provides reports  that are "high-level professional analysis"[4] on various topics to the Congressional committees (more information about the CRS if you're interested can be found on their website here). Because the CRS does all of its research out of the Library of Congress, it too cannot view the cables and, according to this article, will be unable to refer directly to any of the cables; they would have to rely on secondary sources, like newspapers that have cited the leaked documents. Finding the secondary sources to cite may prove difficult, especially after an article I read this morning that discusses the list of secret locations that was released early this week. The article states, "the Associated Press has decided against publishing their names because of the sensitive nature of the information."[5] Well, that's very considerate of the Associated Press, but unfortunately the information is still out there. If Congress requires a report on these topics--for example, in order to determine legislature for future protection of sensitive digital US documents--the CRS would not be able to use anything from the leaked cables themselves. I would bet my year's salary that every country the US has its eye on has these documents and is going over them very carefully, including the location list. So these countries can look through that information all it wants, but the CRS can't? How does this make sense?

I remember seeing a couple of articles saying that LoC claimed they were told to block the site. Unfortunately, I can't find which articles mentioned that (I've read of lot of literature on this topic over the last week), so I can't state whether or not I actually saw those articles or even if the LoC did in fact make those claims. I can say, according to a number of articles including this one on Library Journal, that a memo from the White House's Office of Management and Budget did go out directing federal workers that classified information cannot be accessed on non-classified systems. (The original memo can be found on the TPM Muckraker website.) However, at no point was any office, department, or agency told to block the website. So why did the LoC do it?

That is the million-dollar question. Why did the LoC do it? While they may be the federal archives, they are still a library and should follow those tenets that libraries hold so dear, including advocating against censorship. If our national library (which the LoC really is) will not stand up against censorship, then why do the rest of the nation's public libraries fight so darn hard against it? I feel very saddened by the LoC's choice to take the initiative to censor Wikileaks, first because the block wasn't being required of them and second because libraries are supposed to fight censorship, not promote it.

The staff of the LoC are being very quiet about all this, but I wonder what they would say? Do they agree with the move? Do they feel conflicted about it? Sadly, they are probably being directed to say nothing about it, regardless of what they hear. I would like to know their opinion and perspective on this situation; it may help me to understand why a library, an institution that historically has stood for open access and freedom of information, would choose to close its doors the way the LoC did.

For the record, to date I have not looked at the leaked documents.

[1] Lipton, E. (2010, December 4). Don’t Look, Don’t Read: Government Warns Its Workers Away From WikiLeaks Documents. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/05/world/05restrict.html
[2] Grinberg, E. (2010, December 8). Will reading WikiLeaks cost students jobs with the federal government? CNN.com. Retrieved from http://articles.cnn.com/2010-12-08/justice/wikileaks.students_1_wikileaks-security-clearance-students?_s=PM:CRIME
[3] Progressive Librarians Guild. (2010, December 4). On Wikileaks and the Library of Congress: A Statement by the Progressive Librarians Guild. Retrieved from http://libr.org/plg/lcwikileaks.php
[4] Aftergood, S. (2010, December 6). Blocking Access to Wikileaks May Harm CRS, Analysts Say. Retrieved from http://www.fas.org/blog/secrecy/2010/12/crs_block.html
[5] List reveals secret locations. (2010, December 6). Retrieved from http://www.contracostatimes.com/ci_16794319?IADID=Search-www.contracostatimes.com-www.contracostatimes.com&nclick_check=1

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Copyright Online

Two posts in one day? I know that's rare for me, but I had to help spread the word about a news story brought up in my class discussion forum today. There seems to be a story that's gone viral on the web regarding copyright infringement.

The story basics: a magazine by the name of Cooks Source seems to be getting a lot of its material via copyright infringement. The magazine is literally taking articles found across the web, doing some light re-writing (or no re-writing) and reprinting the articles without giving credit to the original authors. One article, "The Cooks Source Scandal: How a Magazine Profits on Theft," lists six confirmed cases of blatant plagiarism, with possibly more that have just not been discovered or confirmed yet. One of the writers who had her piece lifted without a by-your-leave wrote about it on her livejournal page. She also posted an excerpt from the response she got from the magazine's editor, Judith Griggs. I think that it's criminal that Griggs told the writer "If you took offence and are unhappy, I am sorry, but you as a professional should know that the article we used written by you was in very bad need of editing, and is much better now than was originally" and "We put some time into rewrites, you should compensate me!" The writer is still comtemplating going ahead with legal action; for her sake and the sake of all past and future victims of this magazine's publishing practice, I hope she decides to sue them.

This writer has gotten a lot of support from around the web from other writers and non-writers alike. Neil Gaiman, a published author (and one I really like) also tweeted about it. People seemed to be outraged, and rightly so. The publicity that this story and the topic of copyright has gotten has really made me think about what I post here. I do post recipes, some of which either me or my family have created, and some which I've found online or from other sources. From the ones that I have no claim to, I do always try to give credit to the original source, even though I end up re-writing the steps in the recipe to match the way I end up preparing the food. Copyright can be a slippery slope, and it's a hot topic both in my class and around the web right now.

So I guess I'll close with a word of caution. Give credit where credit is due.

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Information, Knowledge, and Beef Brisket

First of all...GO GIANTS!!!!

Secondly, one of our recent discussions in class has provoked a rather philosophical response from me. The discussion is looking at information vs. knowledge--specifically if there exists a difference between the two--and what characterizes information. I made the point that information doesn't have to be true or false; it really can be either. There are a lot of times where false information can cause problems, especially when considering politics or religious differences. My instructor wanted to know how I would categorize Holocaust deniers or those who believe the moon landing didn't occur. Would this be a case of a knowledge or information problem?

My response:

"I really think that there is a difference between information and knowledge. As I mentioned before, information doesn't have to be right or wrong, so in terms of Holocaust deniers, perhaps the information regarding the Holocaust, while perhaps new (in that it differs from their view and they may not have seen/thought about that perspective), they still see it as false based on their world view. You could almost view this in the same light as religion; a person who follows a particular religious view may (and often does) view the world through his/her belief system. Opposing views, while still being able to be "information" (aka new views that, again, they may not have seen or considered before), could still be viewed as "false" because they don't fit in to the believer's view of the world. So the Holocaust deniers or the folks that don't believe the moon landing happened would be viewing any information on this topic through their own view of those events.

In terms of knowledge, I almost liken it to a philosophical truth, one that would bring us to a higher understanding. This particular thought is hard for me to express in words, but another post you made (mentioning the "truth" of stories and experience) allowed me to focus it a little better. Truth/knowledge can be found in many things, both fact and fiction. For example, in fiction we often times find the truth of our humanity, meaning that we see examples of the true human experience: love, hate, despair, revenge, etc. Did the things in those books actually happen (are they fact?)? No. Is there a greater truth, a message of ourselves that we can learn from them? Yes. But the knowledge (truth) that we each get will be different, based on our personal world view. So maybe then knowledge involves personal interpretation of information.

In answer to the last part of your question, maybe both. These people gleaned truth/knowledge interpreted from information that happens to be contrary to documented evidence (fact). So do we label the information as the cause or their interpretation (where knowledge/understanding occurs) as the cause? For me, it's hard to tell. Since the process of turning information into knowledge (understand/truth) is often times near-instantaneous--as least with me, I find myself judging/interpreting information when I read/see it--it's hard to separate the two in this process."

Anyone want to add to the discussion? Please comment with your own thoughts!

And now this week's recipe. Scooter and I decided to use my crock pot and try a slow cooker recipe. My Better Homes and Gardens cookbook had a recipe for beef brisket with barbecue sauce that Scooter and I agreed to experiment with. It turned out really good and made the apartment smell wonderful!

What you'll need:
3/4 c. water
1/4 c. Worcestershire sauce
1 Tbs. cider vinegar
1 tsp. instant beef bouillon granules
1/2 tsp. dry mustard
1/2 tsp. chili powder
1/4 tsp. cayenne pepper
5 cloves garlic, minced
1 2 1/2 lb. beef brisket
2 Tbs. corn starch
1 c. cold water
1/4 c. honey
1/4 c. brown sugar

What you'll need to do:
1. For cooking liquid, in a bowl combine water, Worcestershire sauce, vinegar, bouillon, mustard, chili powder, cayenne pepper, and garlic.
2. Trim fat from meat. If necessary, cut meat to fit into a 3 1/2- or 4-quart slow cooker. Place meat in cooker and pour liquid over meat.
3. Cover and cook on low-heat setting for 10 to 12 hours or on high-heat setting for 5 to 6 hours.
4. Take some of the cooking liquid and put it into a small saucepan. Over medium heat, add the honey and brown sugar, stir, and cook together until liquid is simmering. In a small bowl, combine the corn starch and cold water and stir until completely dissolved. Add slowly to the saucepan, stir, and cook until slightly thickened.

You can serve the brisket and sauce over potatoes, rice, or even use it to make sandwiches. The cookbook also makes the note that if you have to use a 5- or 6-quart slow cooker, double the cooking liquid. Enjoy!